EarthLink vs Optimum
A detailed head-to-head comparison of EarthLink and Optimum to help you choose the right provider.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | EarthLink | Optimum |
|---|---|---|
| Internet Type | Fiber, Fixed Wireless | Fiber, Cable |
| Max Download Speed | 5 Gbps | 8 Gbps |
| Max Upload Speed | 5 Gbps | 8 Gbps |
| Starting Price | $49.95/mo | $30.00/mo |
| Number of Plans | 6 plans | 5 plans |
| Data Cap | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Contract | None | None |
| Customer Rating | ★★★ 3.8 (12,340 reviews) | ★★★★ 4 (31,250 reviews) |
| Coverage | 50 states | 7 states |
Choose EarthLink If You Want:
- ✓ Unlimited data — no caps or throttling
- ✓ No contract — cancel anytime
- ✓ Fiber internet — most reliable connection
Choose Optimum If You Want:
- ✓ Faster speeds — up to 8 Gbps
- ✓ Lower prices — from $30.00/mo
- ✓ Higher customer satisfaction — 4 stars
- ✓ Better upload speeds — great for remote work
- ✓ Unlimited data — no caps or throttling
- ✓ No contract — cancel anytime
- ✓ Fiber internet — most reliable connection
Plans Comparison
EarthLink Plans
Fiber 100
100 Mbps · Unlimited
$49.95/mo
Fiber 300
300 Mbps · Unlimited
$54.95/mo
Fiber 1 Gig
1 Gbps · Unlimited
$49.95/mo
$74.95/mo
Fiber 2 Gig
2 Gbps · Unlimited
$119.95/mo
Fiber 5 Gig
5 Gbps · Unlimited
$189.95/mo
Wireless Home Internet
200 Mbps · Unlimited
$55.00/mo
Optimum Plans
Fiber 300
300 Mbps · Unlimited
$30.00/mo
Fiber 500
500 Mbps · Unlimited
$40.00/mo
Fiber 1 Gig
1 Gbps · Unlimited
$50.00/mo
Fiber 2 Gig
2 Gbps · Unlimited
$60.00/mo
Fiber 8 Gig
8 Gbps · Unlimited
$90.00/mo
Where Both Are Available
Both EarthLink and Optimum are available in 7 states. Enter your ZIP code to check if both serve your address.
ConnecticutNew JerseyNevadaNew YorkPennsylvaniaTexasWest Virginia
More Provider Comparisons
Verify Your Actual Speeds
EarthLink vs Optimum FAQ
Overall, Optimum edges ahead based on our analysis. Optimum is faster (8 Gbps). Optimum is cheaper (from $30.00/mo). The best choice depends on what's available at your specific address.
Optimum offers faster maximum download speeds at 8 Gbps vs 5 Gbps.
Optimum has more affordable plans starting at $30.00/mo compared to $49.95/mo for EarthLink. Use chat or Talk to Agent for exclusive promotional pricing not listed online.
Both EarthLink and Optimum are available in 7 states, including Connecticut, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania. Enter your ZIP code at the top to check availability at your exact address.
EarthLink offers Fiber, Fixed Wireless internet. Optimum offers Fiber, Cable internet. Fiber internet provides the fastest and most reliable connection.
Internet 4 ALL — Compare EarthLink vs Optimum — find the best deal